Skip to content

Why Do I Owe Taxes This Year? Reasons and Next Steps

Updated Checked by the Tax-Services.ca editorial team How we check

You owe tax when the amount payable on your return is more than your credits and payments. The usual cause is too little tax taken off during the year, such as a second job, side income or self-employment. The CRA says the balance is due April 30, and interest starts the next day.

Next step

Run your own numbers with the Tax Refund Calculator, then read on for the rules behind the result.

Why do I owe money on my taxes if I paid all year?

A balance owing appears when the tax on your return is higher than the credits and payments you have. The CRA's own example is an employer who deducted too little from your pay. Your notice of assessment shows the result, and a balance owing is marked DR. Our guide to reading a notice of assessment walks through each section.

Withholding at work is an estimate based on the information your employer has. If your year turned out differently from that information, the difference shows up when you file.

Can a second job or side income cause a balance?

Yes. The CRA says that when you have more than one employer, you fill in a TD1 for each, but you claim your personal tax credit amounts on only one of them. On the other TD1s you check the box for more than one employer or payer at the same time and enter 0 on line 13. Otherwise an employer will not deduct enough tax compared with your total income. Our page on the TD1 form for 2027 explains when to fill in a new one.

A CRA collections officer, speaking in a CRA podcast, also names unplanned income such as bonuses or capital gains as a source of a surprise bill. If a second employer was never told about the first job through a TD1, the officer says it might not withhold enough tax, if any.

Does self-employment income create a tax bill?

It can, because nobody withholds tax for you. The same CRA officer says self-employed people calculate and remit their own tax, and that missed instalments or underestimated income can build up a debt.

CPP adds to the bill. The CRA's list of who should file says you owe CPP contributions when your net self-employment income plus pensionable employment income is more than $3,500. You also pay EI premiums if you pay them on self-employment or other eligible earnings. Our guide to tax instalments for individuals explains who pays during the year, and the self-employed guide covers the rest.

Can benefit repayments make me owe money?

They can add to what you owe. The CRA lists repaying Old Age Security or Employment Insurance benefits among the reasons a return carries extra amounts.

For OAS, the CRA says you must repay 15% of the amount by which your income is above the threshold. For 2026 the minimum threshold is $95,323, used for the July 2027 to June 2028 recovery period. The CRA page gives no 2027 figure. Once your return is processed, the repayment is divided monthly and deducted from your OAS pension payments, and you receive a letter listing the deductions.

What else can change what I owe?

The CRA officer lists life changes such as a divorce, a job change or retirement. Any of these can make last year's TD1 claims and withholding a poor match for your real year. A second cause is a reassessment: if you claimed a credit or deduction you were not eligible for, you may owe money back, as our page on the notice of reassessment describes.

To see how a different mix of income or credits changes your result, try the income tax calculator before you file.

What should I do when my notice says I owe?

Pay by April 30 of the year after the tax year, if you can. The CRA says interest runs on your full unpaid balance from the day after that date, every day until it is paid. If you cannot pay in full, still file on time, since the CRA says that avoids late-filing penalties.

The CRA lists these ways to pay:

  • online banking, with the CRA added as a payee and your Social Insurance Number as the account number;
  • My Payment, using a debit card;
  • pre-authorized debit through your CRA account;
  • a third-party provider, for credit card, PayPal or Interac e-Transfer;
  • in person at a financial institution or a Canada Post outlet, or by cheque to the Receiver General for Canada.

If you cannot pay in full, contact the CRA about a payment arrangement, which is based on what you can afford. Interest keeps accruing until the balance is paid. If you disagree with the assessment, you have 90 days from the assessment date to file a notice of objection; see how to file a notice of objection. Our page on what to do when you cannot pay a CRA balance goes deeper. The CRA will not ask for payment by gift card, cryptocurrency or text message, so treat any such request as a scam.

What does this look like for one person?

Marcus in Calgary took a weekend job in September while keeping his weekday job. He gave both employers a TD1 with the full personal credits claimed. When he filed in the spring, his notice of assessment showed a balance owing, because neither employer had accounted for his combined income.

He read the notice, then paid before April 30 using online banking so no interest built up. For next year he asked his second employer for a new TD1 with the more-than-one-employer box checked and 0 on line 13.

Frequently asked questions

When is a balance owing due?

The CRA says the deadline to pay a balance owing is April 30 following the tax year. Paying in full by that date avoids interest. Interest applies to your full unpaid balance from the day after the deadline, so file and pay as early as you can.

Do I still have to file if I cannot pay what I owe?

Yes. The CRA says that if you cannot pay in full, you should still file on time to avoid late-filing penalties. Then contact the CRA to ask for a payment arrangement. Interest still builds until the balance is paid in full, so pay what you can as early as possible.

Can I set up payments over time?

The CRA says you can set up a series of payments in your CRA account with a pre-authorized debit agreement, use its automated TeleArrangement service, or speak to a CRA agent. Arrangements are based on what you can afford, and you must make every payment on the arranged dates.

What if I think the assessment is wrong?

A CRA collections officer says you have 90 days from the assessment date to file a notice of objection, and interest continues in the meantime. Check the notice for the exact date and the objection steps. Our page on notices of objection explains the process in more detail.

Why did I owe nothing before and owe now?

The CRA names several causes: a second job where the employer was not told through a TD1, unplanned income such as bonuses or capital gains, self-employment income, and life changes like a job change or retirement. Compare this year's slips with last year's to see which income is new.

Related article

Can't Pay Your CRA Balance Owing? Here's What to Do

Also read

Notice of Assessment Explained: Read Every Section

Share this page